“. . . Especially from a Woman . . .”

Bree McKenna, of the feminist pop punk band TacocaT, has written a thought provoking opinion piece about the letter Leslie Rasmussen wrote to the court in defense of the character of her childhood friend, Stanford rapist Brock Turner, and the backlash against Rasmussen’s band, Good English. However, I was brought up a bit short when I read:

“I would like to make it abundantly clear that her statements offend, confuse and disgust me, especially coming from another woman . . . “

Variations on that phrase, “especially from a woman,” have come up a lot in regard to Rasmussen’s letter. Sadly, this response is understandable, but is it really any worse for a woman to attempt to dismiss a rapist’s guilt and shame the victim? Would the same words be any better coming from a man? Were they any less disgusting coming from Brock Turner’s father?

Doesn’t holding women to a stricter standard play into the noxious idea that rape is just women’s problem, not everyone’s problem?  I don’t mean that only in the sense that men are victims of rape too, but also in the sense that a violent crime against any individual should appall us all equally, regardless of gender. Doesn’t our finding it harder to understand a woman’s seeming lack of empathy with a rape victim reinforce the assumption and even acceptance of men’s indifference (as well as playing into longstanding stereotypes and hegemonic ideals that women are naturally more emotional than men)?

Emma Watson’s speech for the #HeForShe campaign simply proposed that true gender equality cannot happen without men’s embrace (and that men are also restricted by gender ideals):

This idea should have been met with a shrugged “but of course.” Instead, it drew death threats.

Nothing will change until everyone is equally appalled by violations like these.


2 thoughts on ““. . . Especially from a Woman . . .”

  1. Thank you for saying this. It is horrible and dispiriting that this is under discussion in any way in 2016. I guess it’s a silver lining of sorts that we are now talking about this, but honestly? I’m sick of silver linings.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s